Headlines that don't merit their own entry

Tags: pharmaceutical manipulation ∙ doping Western cultures ∙ refugee ∙ IT scandal ∙ Berkeley ∙ UC Berkeley ∙ Milo Yiannopoulos ∙ infrastructure reforms ∙ New York Times ∙ Donald Trump ∙ Charlottesville ∙ speech wars ∙ taxes ∙ food ∙ clothing

What ‘Snowflakes’ Get Right About Free Speech

““Instead of defining freedom of expression as guaranteeing the robust debate from which the truth emerges, Lyotard focused on the asymmetry of different positions when personal experience is challenged by abstract arguments. His extreme example was Holocaust denial, where invidious but often well-publicized cranks confronted survivors with the absurd challenge to produce incontrovertible eyewitness evidence of their experience of the killing machines set up by the Nazis to exterminate the Jews of Europe. Not only was such evidence unavailable, but it also challenged the Jewish survivors to produce evidence of their own legitimacy in a discourse that had systematically denied their humanity.

Lyotard shifted attention away from the content of free speech to the way certain topics restrict speech as a public good. Some things are unmentionable and undebatable, but not because they offend the sensibilities of the sheltered young. Some topics, such as claims that some human beings are by definition inferior to others, or illegal or unworthy of legal standing, are not open to debate because such people cannot debate them on the same terms.

The recent student demonstrations at Auburn against Spencer’s visit — as well as protests on other campuses against Charles Murray, Milo Yiannopoulos and others — should be understood as an attempt to ensure the conditions of free speech for a greater group of people, rather than censorship. Liberal free-speech advocates rush to point out that the views of these individuals must be heard first to be rejected. But this is not the case. Universities invite speakers not chiefly to present otherwise unavailable discoveries, but to present to the public views they have presented elsewhere. When those views invalidate the humanity of some people, they restrict speech as a public good.””
     — Ulrich Baer

h/t Bookworm Room

Tags: Jean-François Lyotard ∙ Holocaust denial ∙ Auburn University ∙ Richard Spencer ∙ Charles Murray ∙ Milo Yiannopoulos ∙ Ulrich Baer ∙ clipping